
You hear about sexual abuses against inmates in other countries but you may not think that it happens in almost half of the states in the US. This article does raise an important question. Are illegal immigrants guaranteed the same rights as citizens of the United States because the undocumented immigrants have entered the country in an illegal way? I believe that this is not an accuse for illegal immigrants to be abused. Illegal immigrants are still human and should not be sexually abused because they broke a law. However, there are other arguments that once someone breaks the law they may not be guaranteed the same rights as others who abide by the law. I believe that this article deals with the violation of liberty and security of a person. When women are in a jail there security should not be at risk, especially from officers that are taking advantage of them. I also believe that this violates humane treatment when detained or imprisoned. These women are being raped, inappropriately touched, and some even fear for their lives.
Do you believe that these women should still be guaranteed their human rights even though they entered into the United States illegally?
http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2011/oct/19/sexual-abuse-immigration-detention-aclu?newsfeed=true
I do not believe that this violation of human rights has anything to do with the women being illegal. The reason that more cases are occurring is because more illegal immigrants are now being entered and held under the law for being illegal. There are cases of sexual abuse in prisons every where in the United States, it just so happens that we have added a new category of people entering into the jail facilities. It is only normal that they too would be effected by an issue that has been present in our prison system for a long time. It has nothing to do with them being illegal. Of course everyone should still be granted their human rights in our country while being detained. We have international laws that we are to follow for illegals that are held in our country until deported. This is not an issue of granting rights based on the severity of breaking the law. Rights are granted because international law has stated they be and when they are violated they should be addressed without turning it into an "illegal" issue.
ReplyDeleteYes, human rights should apply to all whether they enter a country illegally or not. This is the same case if we were to go into another country and completely lose our human rights and be detained without trial or any of the other rights we have. The problem here is that the illegal immigrant issue is such a blind eye issue within the country and even in others that we turn a special blind eye to their abuses within our own system. Its not that jail rapes do not happen to our own citizens it is more that we have turned a complete blind eye to illegal immigrants and therefore do not know what to do when their rights are violated.
ReplyDelete